Bobbi Brown’s new brand Jones Road Beauty also offers The Best Pencil Eyeliner. It’s a pigment-saturated, dense, and ’70s-inspired formula that’s also clean. It’s excellent for smudging on lids for that next day, “I slept in my makeup look,” without actually sleeping in your makeup. You can swipe the product onto lids and then smudge with your fingers. The natural oils in your hands will turn it into a sooty, sexy, and smoky swirl. It can also be used to line lower lashlines and the waterline with its precise point. Or you can just take your aforementioned finger and smudge away. The pencil-like look will also transport you to a simpler time.